Wednesday, October 28, 2026

"Dating Hishtadlus"

@elainechaya has captured my heart. I only discovered her now with her wedding recaps, yet she's continuing to post regarding the divine plan when it comes to bashert. 

Under one of her posts, someone left a snide comment about how easy it is for her to talk about divine timing after the fact. Yet it's what I learned too—there was nothing I did that lead to the desired outcome. It's not like that I saw a distinct line between chasing after shadchanim and attending torturous singles events and dabbling with online dating. It was nothing I had done in the name of "hishtadlus," or rather "proving to everyone that I was doing my hishtadlus." 

What's difficult about so-called "dating hishtadlus" is that there are no specific parameters to abide by. "Going to shadchanim" doesn't really mean anything, because there are a bazillion shadchanim and going to them all isn't really feasible and who knows if that shadchan actually knows or would even set you up with your bashert? 

Same for singles events—I hadn't gone to many, but according to Han, pretty much the same people are at events: the ones who are willing to attend them. So one meets the same people over and over.

"Dating hishtadlus" is not the same as other hishtadlus. Like "making the train hishtadlus." There are clear parameters. Get up early. Dress for the weather. Leave the house on time. If a lightning bolt cracks into a tree which falls across the road and your car is trapped, well, you did your hishtadlus. 

But that's not how "dating hishtadlus" is perceived. If one isn't married by a socially acceptable narrow age range you are huffily told you aren't doing "enough." Whatever "enough" is. If you try to invoke some emunah or bitachon you're told you're an idiot—until after you marry.  

The only real dating advice is self-improvement. The best way to meet an incredible person is to become an incredible person. — Mark Manson 

That's the only real, tangible dating hishtadlus. 

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Matchmaker Mystique

The NY Times (yes, they're a bunch of antisemites or self-haters, but they offered Ta a reduced rate after he threatened to cancel his subscription) had an article about the world of high-priced matchmaking. It was rather interesting, yet what caught my eye was a comment by the author, Catherine Pearson: 

Part of what drew me to this story was simply wanting to understand more about what high-end matchmaking is and how it works. This didn't make the final cut, but one longtime matchmaker I interviewed said it's almost impossible to consumers to make thoughtful decisions about whether the people they are hiring are qualified or charging fair rates. As she told me: anyone can call themselves a matchmaker. And the industry can be really opaque! 

Yep. Yep yep yep yep yep. 

I see this question a lot on social media: "Can someone recommend a shadchan who deals with ________?" And this isn't for something odd an obscure, like "fans of the original Star Wars trilogy that hate everything since then," but rather "middle of the road girls aged 20-23"? 

I'm the first one there to burst the bubble. 

This question typically gets asked by someone who is not familiar with the concept of "shadchan." They visualize an accredited, licensed professional with a wall of framed diplomas, when in reality it can be someone who just decided a few days ago that she wants to be a shadchan. 

Don't get me wrong, there are some shadchanim who made a lot of shidduchim. By "a lot," I mean around 25. That's a lot! I know of one with that many success stories. Yet her own daughter was single until 30 (and her mother was not her shadchan). But chances are she has hundreds of other people in her database. Going to her and expecting her, specifically, to match you up with Prince Charming isn't very realistic. 

I have been to shadchanim with a "name." No dates, not even a suggestion. I have been to obscure shadchanim. No, dates, not even a suggestion. I have been to shadchanim who sit on a panel with other shadchanim, and the one date they suggested was my brother's oddball classmate. When I passed, they wouldn't take no for an answer. 

They finally crunched the numbers and realized that "professional" shadchanim make less than a quarter of marriages. Statistics-wise, it makes more sense to rely on one's social circle. 

I am not saying that one shouldn't go to a "professional" shadchan. I'm saying, manage your expectations. She is not a guaranteed bashert fairy. She will not listen to your detailed list of desires and magically pluck someone who meets them all out of a hat. She's not Dr. Frankenstein, she's can't assemble him in her laboratory. 

We think to ourselves, going to a shadchan is hishtadlus! In my case, not remotely. It usually ended up being a torturous, mortifying experience when I was told I was being unrealistic for having 2.5 standards. The one shadchan who was really sweet and didn't badger me only invited me to catastrophic single events. 

Don't put your faith in a shadchan. While they can claim they make the rules, they don't.